Manuscript Critique and Editing with Deep, Constructive Feedback
This is a ready-made prompt from the Zayenha Prompt library in Content Writing, written for gemini-3-pro. It has a main prompt to copy into the model, built-in quality guards, and a verification prompt to run in a second window to review the answer. The full text needs the Pro plan; the description is open to all.
Critique a book manuscript with deep developmental feedback diagnosing structure, voice, pace, and gaps, offering a practical improvement path with examples, for an author before publishing, without fabricating quotes from the text or verdicts unsupported by it.
Your current plan: free
Reviewing a book manuscript before publishing, getting developmental feedback on a draft, diagnosing why a chapter or manuscript falls short and a plan to fix it.
Built-in quality guards
No quoting phrases absent from the text, issuing verdicts without textual evidence, or inventing problems
Cover overall assessment, structure, voice, gaps, and improvement path
Every note is backed by a specific quote from the provided text
The manuscript is judged against its target reader and the book's goal, not a generic standard
Frequently asked questions
How do I use this prompt?
Copy the main prompt and paste it into gemini-3-pro or the model you use, replace what is in square brackets with your details, then run the verification prompt in a second window with the answer pasted in, and review it before relying on it.
Is this prompt free?
Its full text requires the Pro plan or higher. Free prompts you can copy at once without an account are on the ready-made Arabic prompts page.
Which model was this prompt written for?
It was written for gemini-3-pro and follows how that model works; you can run it on other models too, reviewing the result, since no single wording guarantees the best result on every model.