Constructive Peer-Review Report
Write a methodical peer-review report across contribution, methods, results, and ethics, with a justified publication recommendation and actionable comments, without fabricating flaws or references.
Pro
Model: claude-sonnet-4-7
3,801 previews
0 uses
Knowledge: 2026-Q2
This prompt requires the pro plan
Upgrade plan
Your current plan: free
Writing a review report for a peer-reviewed journal, reviewing a colleague's manuscript before submission, training graduate students on constructive peer-review standards.
#تحكيم علمي#peer review#مراجعة أقران#جودة البحث
Built-in quality guards
Anti-hallucination
No fabricated flaws or references to justify criticism
Completeness
Cover all review axes without neglecting ethics
Specialist Review
Substantive concerns referred to the editor for specialist verification
Sources
Any reference-based criticism backed by a verified, not fabricated, source